Professional Football Researchers Association Forum

Here are which players got voted first and second team all pro this season.

Thoughts on who they got right and wrong and who you would’ve picked?

First Team

Arizona Cardinals: Trey McBride (TE)
Atlanta Falcons: Bijan Robinson (RB, All-Purpose)
Baltimore Ravens: Kyle Hamilton (S), Jordan Stout (P)
Buffalo Bills: Ray Davis (KR)
Chicago Bears: Joe Thuney (LG), Kevin Byard (S)
Cincinnati Bengals: Ja'Marr Chase (WR)
Cleveland Browns: Myles Garrett (Edge)
Denver Broncos: Garrett Bolles (LT), Quinn Meinerz (RG), Zach Allen (IDL), Devon Key (ST)
Detroit Lions: Penei Sewell (RT), Jack Campbell (LB)
Green Bay Packers: Micah Parsons (Edge)
Houston Texans: Will Anderson Jr. (Edge), Derek Stingley Jr. (CB)
Jacksonville Jaguars: Ross Matiscik (LS)
Kansas City Chiefs: Creed Humphrey (C)
Los Angeles Rams: Matthew Stafford (QB), Puka Nacua (WR)
Minnesota Vikings: Will Reichard (K)
Philadelphia Eagles: Quinyon Mitchell (CB), Cooper DeJean (Slot CB)
San Francisco 49ers: Kyle Juszczyk (FB), Christian McCaffrey (All-Purpose)
Seattle Seahawks: Jaxon Smith-Njigba (WR)
Tennessee Titans: Jeffery Simmons (IDL), Chimere Dike (PR)
Miami Dolphins: Jordyn Brooks (LB)
Second Team

Atlanta Falcons: Bijan Robinson (All-Purpose), Kyle Pitts (TE), Chris Lindstrom (RG), Jessie Bates III (S)
Baltimore Ravens: Patrick Ricard (FB)
Buffalo Bills: James Cook (RB)
Chicago Bears: Darnell Wright (RT)
Dallas Cowboys: George Pickens (WR), Brandon Aubrey (K), Kavontae Turpin (KR)
Denver Broncos: Patrick Surtain II (CB), Talanoa Hufanga (S)*
Detroit Lions: Amon-Ra St. Brown (WR), Aidan Hutchinson (Edge)
Green Bay Packers: Xavier McKinney (S)*
Houston Texans: Danielle Hunter (Edge)
Indianapolis Colts: Quenton Nelson (LG)
Jacksonville Jaguars: Devin Lloyd (LB)
Los Angeles Chargers: Derwin James (Slot CB), Del'Shawn Phillips (ST)
Miami Dolphins: Aaron Brewer (C)
Minnesota Vikings: Andrew DePaola (LS)
New England Patriots: Drake Maye (QB), Marcus Jones (PR)
New Orleans Saints: Chris Olave (WR)
New York Giants: Brian Burns (Edge)
Pittsburgh Steelers: Cameron Heyward (IDL)
San Francisco 49ers: Trent Williams (LT)
Seattle Seahawks: Leonard Williams (IDL), Ernest Jones IV (LB), Devon Witherspoon (CB), Michael Dickson (P)

I mentioned this team at length on Pro Football Journal ...

Stafford and Maye will battle for MVP, athough I would vote for McCaffrey, as AP has now added a second, All-Purpose RB to both teams. Robinson got selected to both teams, with Gibbs and Achane missing out on 2nd team all-purpose. Taylor and Henry were also omitted despite being #1 and #4 in overrall TDs scored.

Dont agree with Pitts being 2nd Team TE, though John Turney did.
He only scored 1 TD prior to the wk 15 showdown with TB, where he scored 3 of his 5 TDs. He did surge late and helped the team win their last four games, which stayed in voters minds.

Chase was voted 1st team WR but Adams, St Brown and Pickens had more impact, I believe.

The Edge rushers on both teams are a mess. You had Anderson and Parsons getting the nod on 1st team with Garrett as the DE.
Is Parsons considered an OLB selection? On the second team its Burns at Edge with Hunter or Hutchinson at DE. Is one of them considered at OLB?

Pitre didnt make it as a slot corner/safety but James did. Very close. Surprised that Surtain was 2nd team after being DPOY last year?

Simmons was great at DT/DI but Murphy missed out for Seattle.
Glad Burns and Hunter made these teams.

Brian wolf wrote: ↑Sat Jan 10, 2026 2:41 pm I mentioned this team at length on Pro Football Journal ...

Stafford and Maye will battle for MVP, athough I would vote for McCaffrey, as AP has now added a second, All-Purpose RB to both teams. Robinson got selected to both teams, with Gibbs and Achane missing out on 2nd team all-purpose. Taylor and Henry were also omitted despite being #1 and #4 in overrall TDs scored.

Dont agree with Pitts being 2nd Team TE, though John Turney did.
He only scored 1 TD prior to the wk 15 showdown with TB, where he scored 3 of his 5 TDs. He did surge late and helped the team win their last four games, which stayed in voters minds.

Chase was voted 1st team WR but Adams, St Brown and Pickens had more impact, I believe.

The Edge rushers on both teams are a mess. You had Anderson and Parsons getting the nod on 1st team with Garrett as the DE.
Is Parsons considered an OLB selection? On the second team its Burns at Edge with Hunter or Hutchinson at DE. Is one of them considered at OLB?

Pitre didnt make it as a slot corner/safety but James did. Very close. Surprised that Surtain was 2nd team after being DPOY last year?

Simmons was great at DT/DI but Murphy missed out for Seattle.
Glad Burns and Hunter made these teams.

Is Pitts a good blocker?

Also, one player who I think would have gotten some consideration for this would be Jared Verse of the Rams at linebacker.

Then again not sure who of Llyod, Jones, Brooks, and Campbell I’d remove if any of them.

Verse disappoints me. Yes, he gets the pressures but cant bring the QBs, down. He doesnt want to end up being compared to Clowney, who could also stop the run. Good year for Kobe Turner as well but not like his rookie year. What happened with Fiske?

Brian wolf wrote: ↑Sat Jan 10, 2026 4:52 pm Verse disappoints me. Yes, he gets the pressures but cant bring the QBs, down. He doesnt want to end up being compared to Clowney, who could also stop the run. Good year for Kobe Turner as well but not like his rookie year. What happened with Fiske?

I remember Clowney on the Seahawks in 2019. He only has three sacks, but I remember him drawing a lot of double teams, and stopping runs on his side well.

saw a few posts about Kittle getting a first team vote, causing McBride a unanimous selection.

Yup. Voting totals in the link:

https://apnews.com/article/nfl-all-pro- ... 3b2e1de3c3

Thanks Reaser ... close vote on 1st team between Bolles and Williams.