Professional Football Researchers Association Forum

frankly since the 2020 Centennial class, the voters have made a complete mess of the coach queue, now only made worse by having them compete directly with seniors and contributors.

Its a very interesting question as Meredith got the team to back to back NFL Championship games while White got them to back to back to back NFC championship games, in terms of talent (given their respect eras) I would go with Meredith-especially considering both GB losses were very close Romo (prev...

Brady,Montana,Unitas,PManning,Graham,Mahomes,Marino,Rodgers,Elway,Farve

I like his case, but man there is a long queue of deserving seniors ahead of him (in recent years he has not made the 25+ semifinalist list) and electing just one a year, hard to see a path to election for Ottis

update-still no news on any election changes made by Hall Board when they met this week in Canton, recently messaged with a few voters and they were not aware of any (but they all suspect some changes likely), possible we will not see official Hall announcement for a few weeks but will watch to see ...

I have always wanted a more transaparent election system for the Seniors, like semifinalists and finalists as in the open pool. not sure what you mean as one of the few recent improvements to the election process was a process by which the seniors committee vets a large preliminary list of senior c...

Even if he retired today, I would place him around 8th or so all time. I am always amazed more people don't realize and appreciate the historical career he has already had-not many other QBs in NFL history have 3 league championship (only 9 have achieved that) plus 2 NFL MVPs and he was the best pla...

Eagles One wrote: ↑Mon Aug 03, 2026 12:10 am During the Super Bowl era which excludes Brown, Halas, Lambeau, I would have Noll, Walsh, Gibbs and maybe Parcells ahead of Reid.

Not Bill Belichick???
Not Vince Lombardi???
Not Don Shula??
Not Tom Landry???

For me Reid sits around 10th or 11th all time, perhaps 8th or so in SB era

Cowboys 1980-1982, not as talented as 1970s team but with Danny White at QB they still went to three consecutive NFCC games

KC Chiefs of mid 60s to early 70s-great coach and plenty of PFHOFers yet just one SB